Can I Renounce an Inheritance or Sell My Share Before Probate Ends?
How an inheritance is accepted or renounced, the deadline, where the share of someone who renounces goes, and how to sell an inheritance share before division.
Translated from the Spanish original. If there is any discrepancy between the two versions, the Spanish text prevails. Read the original in Spanish.
In this article6 sections
Three siblings inherit their father’s farm. One lives in San José, wants nothing to do with the process, and needs money now. A neighbor offers to buy his share. A sister would rather receive nothing, because she fears the inheritance will bring her problems. Both things are possible, but the law sets rules worth knowing before signing anything.
How is an inheritance accepted or renounced?
Accepting and renouncing are free and voluntary acts, with clear limits: they cannot be done in part, for a fixed term, or subject to a condition, and they cannot be done by someone who does not have free management of their own property. Either you accept your whole share, or you renounce all of it.
- Accepting. To have all its effects, acceptance must be express: you ask the probate judge to declare you an heir. The deadline is fifteen business days from publication of the notice in the Judicial Bulletin (Boletín Judicial). If your name and address appear in the court file, the deadline runs from the date you are personally served. If personal service was not required and you live outside the country, the deadline is extended by thirty more business days, solely for purposes of the fruits, meaning income from the assets.
- After the deadline. The heir may still claim the inheritance from whoever holds it, as long as the right has not become time-barred. And if the heir dies before accepting, their own heirs may use the time that remained.
- Renouncing. The renunciation must also be express and made before the judge hearing the probate proceedings (proceso sucesorio).
What happens to my share if I renounce?
It does not go to whomever you choose: the law decides. It applies two rules, always in this order:
- First, representation (representación). To represent someone is to enter the inheritance in that person’s place and receive the share that person would have received. If someone can represent the person who renounced, the share goes to them.
- Then, the right of accretion (derecho de acrecer). Only if no one can represent the person who renounced does their share “accrue,” meaning it is added to the shares of the other heirs, who divide it among themselves.
The two rules do not contradict each other: the second applies only when the first does not. The answer also changes depending on whether or not there is a will.
Without a will: who can take your place?
The law allows representation only in favor of two groups: the descendants of the deceased (children, grandchildren, and great-grandchildren) and the nephews and nieces of the deceased. In practice, that leaves two cases:
- If you renounce the inheritance of your father or mother, your children may take your place, because they are grandchildren of the deceased.
- If you renounce the inheritance of a brother or sister, your children may take your place, because they are nephews or nieces of the deceased.
Those who take your place do not receive more than your share: they divide your share in equal portions. Nor are they required to take it: they too may accept or renounce. If any of them is a minor, the rules we explain in this other publication apply.
Grandchildren in place of a son who renounces. Don Carlos was a widower and died without a will. He leaves three children, Ana, Luis, and Marta, and each is entitled to one third. Luis renounces. Because he has two children, Sofía and Diego, they step into his place and divide their father’s third: one sixth each. Ana and Marta keep their third. Luis’s renunciation does not increase his sisters’ shares at all.
A niece in place of a brother who renounces. Doña Rosa died single, without children and without a will, and her parents and grandparents were no longer living. Her heirs are her two brothers, Juan and Pedro, in equal halves. Pedro renounces, and he has a daughter, Laura. Because Laura is doña Rosa’s niece, she receives the half that would have gone to her father.
Without a will: if no one takes your place, your share is added to the others’
Your share accrues to the other heirs when there is no representation. This happens, for example:
- when the person who renounces has no children;
- when their children also renounce;
- when the person who renounces is the father, mother, spouse, or cohabiting partner of the deceased. Their other relatives are not descendants or nephews or nieces of the deceased, so they cannot take their place.
A son who renounces and has no children. Back to don Carlos. If Luis renounces and has no children, no one can take his place. His third is divided between Ana and Marta, and each ends up with half of the inheritance.
A mother who renounces. Don Jorge died single, without a partner, without children, and without a will. His heirs are his father and mother, in equal halves. His mother renounces. Her other children, who are don Jorge’s siblings, cannot take her place, because they are not descendants or nephews or nieces of the deceased. The mother’s half is added to the father’s, and he becomes the sole heir.
If the person who renounces was the only one in their group. The law places heirs in groups, in order, and a group inherits only if no one is left in the one before it. If don Carlos had had only one child, his parents had already died, and that child renounced without having children, no one would be left in the first group. The inheritance would then pass to the next one: the grandparents; if there are none, the siblings; and so on. We explain the full order in this other publication.
With a will
- The share of the person who renounces goes to the other heirs named in the will, unless the testator provided otherwise. The testator may have provided, for example, that if someone does not accept, their share goes to another person.
- The law does not call the children of the person who renounces. For wills, the law provides that the descendants or nephews and nieces of the testator may take the place of an heir who died before the testator. For an heir who renounces, it says no such thing: the rule is that their share goes to the other heirs. If the testator wants the children of the person who renounces to receive it in that case, it is best to write that into the will.
- If no other heirs remain under the will, the share of the person who renounces is distributed as if there were no will, among the heirs called by law and under the rules described above.
An example. Doña Elena left a will naming her children, Ana and Luis, and her friend Carmen as heirs to all her property in equal shares. Carmen renounces, and her third is added to Ana’s and Luis’s: each receives half. If doña Elena had written “if Carmen does not accept, her share will go to the Red Cross,” that third would go to the Red Cross. And if Carmen had been the only heir under the will, once she renounced the inheritance would pass to Ana and Luis as heirs without a will.
What if the person who renounces is a legatee?
A legatee (legatario) is someone who receives a specific asset under a will, such as a house, a car, or a sum of money. If a legatee renounces, that asset does not pass to the other legatees: it stays with the heirs.
An example. Doña Elena left her car to her neighbor Mario and the rest of her property to her children. If Mario renounces, the car stays with the children. If she had left it to two neighbors jointly and one renounced, the other would not receive the half of the one who renounced: that half would belong to the heirs. Because a car cannot be split, the neighbor who accepted could choose. He may keep the whole car and pay the heirs the value of the other half, or receive from them the value of his own half.
Other rules on renunciation
- It is final. A renunciation made in proper form cannot be challenged, except where there was lack of consent, fraud, force, or violence. There is one exception: someone who renounced an inheritance without a will may later claim it under a will they did not know about.
- Your creditors may challenge it. If you have debts and you renounce, your creditors may attack the renunciation and collect from what you would have received, in the cases and within the time periods in which the law allows them to annul acts done to their detriment.
- It does not let you choose who receives your share. If you want your share to reach a sibling or some other particular person, renouncing will not do it. The way to do it is to accept the inheritance and assign your share to that person, as we explain below.
If what worries you is the deceased’s debts, renouncing is not always necessary: the heir is liable only up to the value of the estate’s assets. We explain this in this article.
Can I renounce before my relative dies?
No. Renouncing the inheritance of a living person has no legal effect. In addition, nothing can be agreed about the rights to someone’s inheritance while that person is alive, even if that person consents. A document in which a son “renounces” while his mother is alive, or in which he promises to sell what he will inherit someday, is worthless.
Can I sell my share before the estate is divided?
Yes. The Civil Code allows an inheritance right to be assigned, and if it is assigned for a price in money, the rules on sales apply. What is sold is the share in the inheritance, not the farm or any specific asset. The law sets these effects:
- The seller hands over everything received. This includes what the seller has already received as an heir and the fruits they have consumed, unless something is expressly reserved.
- The buyer reimburses what was paid. The buyer must repay the seller whatever the seller paid in the capacity of heir.
- The status of heir is guaranteed. The seller guarantees that they are an heir, but not that a specific asset believed to belong to the estate actually does, unless otherwise agreed.
- Later accretions are not included. The buyer cannot claim what the seller receives through the right of accretion after the sale, unless otherwise agreed.
The buyer, called the assignee (cesionario), takes part in the probate proceedings. In a 1999 case, the First Civil Court of Appeals (Tribunal Primero Civil) heard a probate case in which a person from outside the family, who had acquired the rights of one of the heirs, asked for the executor (albacea) to be removed. The Court treated him as one more co-heir: it denied the removal, but urged the trial court to call the interested parties together, including the assignee, to seek an agreement that would end the proceedings. The full probate procedure is explained in this article.
Practical recommendations
- Find out who will receive your share before renouncing. If you have children, it may end up with them rather than with your siblings. If you want a particular person to receive it, do not renounce: accept and assign your share to that person.
- Count the deadline. It is fifteen business days from the notice or from the date you are personally served.
- Put the sale in writing, before a notary public (civil-law notary), with the price and what it includes: what has already been received, the fruits, and anything that may accrue.
- Do not sign renunciations or sales concerning the inheritance of someone who is still alive: they are not valid.
Need help?
At Murillo y Guzmán we can explain what happens to your share if you renounce, prepare the public deed assigning inheritance rights, and file it in the probate proceedings. Book a consultation.
This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice for any specific case. To discuss your situation, book a consultation.
Related insights
-
Inheritance
Inventory and Appraisal: How Do You Know What Makes Up the Estate and What It Is Worth?
Who prepares the estate inventory, how the value of each asset is set, and what to do if an heir believes an asset is missing or does not belong in...
-
Inheritance
Life Insurance, Pensions, and Savings: Are They Part of the Estate?
Life insurance with a beneficiary, survivor pensions, and accounts or certificates with named beneficiaries are not divided in the estate; other mo...
-
Inheritance
An Heir Lives Abroad or Cannot Be Found: Does Probate Come to a Halt?
If an heir lives abroad or cannot be found, probate goes on. How the heir is notified, who represents them, what happens to their share, and how to...
Comments
Loading comments…
Thank you. Your comment is awaiting review and will be published if it complies with the comment policy.