Ciudad Quesada, San Carlos, Costa Rica · Barrio San Martín (Gamonales), across from the EBAIS (public health clinic) Phone +506 2460-7226 [email protected]

InheritanceInsurancePensions and Social SecurityBanking

Life Insurance, Pensions, and Savings: Are They Part of the Estate?

Life insurance with a beneficiary, survivor pensions, and accounts or certificates with named beneficiaries are not divided in the estate; other money is.

Translated from the Spanish original. If there is any discrepancy between the two versions, the Spanish text prevails. Read the original in Spanish.

In this article6 sections
  1. Is life insurance part of the estate?
  2. What happens if the beneficiary dies?
  3. What about the pension?
  4. What about bank accounts and certificates of deposit?
  5. Practical recommendations
  6. Need help?

A bank employee dies. Among his papers, his daughter finds the certificate for a group life insurance policy from his job, naming her as beneficiary, and statements for a savings account and a certificate of deposit. Her mother asks whether the pension she is about to request from the Social Security Fund (Caja Costarricense de Seguro Social) will also be divided among the siblings. Each of these follows different rules, and not all of them are part of the estate.

Is life insurance part of the estate?

If the policy has a beneficiary, that is, someone designated to receive the insurance money, the insurer must pay that person, even against the claims of the creditors of whoever took out the policy, unless the premiums were paid to defraud them. In group insurance, such as the policies an employer takes out for its workers, the beneficiary has a right of their own against the insurer from the moment the death occurs. That money is not divided in probate.

Only the insured person can designate, change, or revoke the beneficiary. The change takes effect once the insurer is informed. If there are several beneficiaries and no shares were set for each one, the money is divided equally.

What happens if the beneficiary dies?

Here it matters who died first. The right to the insurance money arises at the moment the insured person dies, and only a beneficiary who is still alive at that moment acquires it.

  • If the beneficiary died before the insured person, she never acquired the right. Her share is added to the shares of the other beneficiaries, who receive more than the policy assigned them. This is what the law calls “accrual” (acrecer). The share does not go to the heirs of the beneficiary who died.
  • If they died at the same moment, the same thing happens: the share is added to the others’. Dying on the same day is not enough. But when it is impossible to know who died first, as sometimes happens in the same accident, the law presumes that they died at the same moment.
  • If the beneficiary died after the insured person without having collected, even by a few hours, she did acquire the right. Her share passes to her own heirs, who will have to show in her probate proceedings that they are her heirs.
  • If all the beneficiaries died before or at the same moment as the insured person, or if no one was ever designated, the money goes to the insured person’s legal heirs, as established in the probate proceedings. In that case probate is needed, at least to determine who they are.

An example with figures. Don Luis has a ₡20 million life insurance policy and named his sister Ana and his daughter Lucía as beneficiaries, half each.

  • Ana dies before Don Luis, or in the same accident without anyone knowing who died first: Lucía receives the full ₡20 million.
  • Ana dies three days after Don Luis, without having collected: Lucía receives ₡10 million and Ana’s heirs receive the other ₡10 million.
  • Ana and Lucía both die before Don Luis: the ₡20 million goes to Don Luis’s legal heirs.

A beneficiary who causes the death of the insured person through intent or gross negligence loses the right. In that case, the share is not added to the others’: the insurer is released from paying it. And the claim against the insurer lapses four years after the right becomes enforceable.

What about the pension?

The survivor pension paid by the Social Security Fund is not an asset the deceased leaves behind to be divided. It is a right that belongs to certain family members in their own name, and they request it directly from the Fund. Under the Disability, Old Age, and Death Insurance Regulations (Reglamento del Seguro de Invalidez, Vejez y Muerte), it may go to the surviving partner, including, in certain cases, a divorced spouse who was receiving alimony; to children who were financially dependent on the deceased and were minors, students under 25, or disabled; and, in certain cases, to parents, to those who acted as parents, or to siblings who were dependent on the deceased. In addition, the deceased must have been a pensioner or have made enough contributions. The right to claim a survivor pension lapses after ten years.

The rule for the mandatory supplementary pension is similar. If the member dies, the balance goes, in this order, to the beneficiaries under the Fund’s pension system; failing them, to those the member designated with their pension fund manager; and, if there are none, anyone with an interest may claim it before the labor court. If no one withdraws those funds within ten years after the death, the right lapses.

The deceased worker’s employment benefits also follow their own path, outside probate. We will explain this in an upcoming article.

What about bank accounts and certificates of deposit?

It depends on whether the account holder named beneficiaries.

The Securities Market Regulation Law (Ley Reguladora del Mercado de Valores) allows the holder to designate beneficiaries, in case of death, for savings accounts, checking accounts, certificates of deposit, and term savings contracts. The rule applies to the institutions supervised by the General Superintendency of Financial Institutions (Superintendencia General de Entidades Financieras): public and private banks, mutual associations (mutuales), finance companies, and the savings and credit cooperatives it supervises. Employee solidarity associations (asociaciones solidaristas) and some small cooperatives are outside that supervision, so their own rules must be checked. Beneficiaries can also be named for investment funds, securities accounts, and supplementary pension funds. In the mandatory supplementary pension, however, the people named only collect if there are no beneficiaries under the Social Security Fund’s system, as explained above.

Naming beneficiaries is voluntary, but today it is common for financial institutions to offer it and recommend it when someone opens an account or a certificate. It can be done on paper or digitally, and the holder can change it at any time. If the certificate renews automatically, the designation remains valid for the renewals unless the holder changes it. If the certificate is transferred to another person, the designation is no longer effective.

If there are beneficiaries, when the holder dies they become the owners of that money by operation of law, including principal and interest. They only need to present proof of the death and their identification at the institution, with no lawsuit, no probate, and no other procedures. As a rule, that money is not part of the estate: the person named with the institution collects it, even if the will says otherwise. If the holder wants it to go to someone else, they must change the beneficiaries with the institution. Some institutions pay out a certificate only when it matures, so it is worth asking.

If there are no beneficiaries, the money is part of the estate, because the estate includes all the assets and rights of the deceased. It is included in the inventory and divided among the heirs named in the will or, if there is none, according to the order of inheritance set by law. If there is a risk that someone will withdraw the money, the court can order the banks to freeze the accounts.

In the example at the beginning, the daughter must ask the bank whether her father named beneficiaries for the savings account and the certificate. If he did, those people collect directly. If not, that money goes into the probate proceedings.

What if the beneficiary died before the holder? The holder can change their beneficiaries at any time, and should do so as soon as one of them dies. If they do not, and they die when that beneficiary had already died, the beneficiary’s heirs could claim that they are entitled to the money in the account or certificate. Unlike what happens with life insurance, this law does not say that the share is added to the shares of the other beneficiaries, and that can end in a dispute between families.

Can the deceased’s creditors collect? It depends on who gets there first. If a creditor obtains a court order freezing the accounts before the beneficiary withdraws the money, the creditor could collect from it. If the beneficiary withdraws the money before that order, they had no reason to know whether the holder had debts: the money is theirs because the law expressly authorizes it. In addition, some institutions first deduct what the deceased owed them.

What about the spouse? The law does not say whether the surviving spouse keeps their right to half of that money when the account was built up during the marriage. We address this in this other publication.

Practical recommendations

  1. Look for insurance policies, including group policies from work and those tied to loans. The insurance law requires the General Superintendency of Insurance (Superintendencia General de Seguros) to maintain a registry so that people can check whether they are beneficiaries of a life insurance policy of someone who has died.
  2. If you are a beneficiary, file your claim directly with the insurer and do not wait for probate. The deadline is four years.
  3. Ask each bank, cooperative, or pension fund manager whether the deceased named beneficiaries for their accounts, certificates, and funds.
  4. Do not withdraw money on your own from accounts without beneficiaries. That money is managed and divided within the probate proceedings.
  5. Review the beneficiaries of your own accounts, certificates, policies, and funds. For accounts, certificates, and policies, that money will go to whoever is named there, not to whoever your will says. If someone has died or your family situation has changed, update them.

Need help?

Telling apart what belongs to the estate and what does not prevents disputes among family members. At Murillo y Guzmán we can review the deceased’s insurance policies, pensions, and accounts, and advise you on where to file each claim. Book a consultation.

This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice for any specific case. To discuss your situation, book a consultation.

All insights Share

Related insights

Comments

Loading comments…