Do I Have to Pay the Debts of a Relative Who Died?
A deceased person's debts are paid with the estate's assets, not with the family's money. How creditors collect and what to do if they call the family.
Translated from the Spanish original. If there is any discrepancy between the two versions, the Spanish text prevails. Read the original in Spanish.
A week after Don Jorge died, the calls began: the bank, the store where he bought a refrigerator on installments, and a moneylender. They are all asking his widow and children to pay what he owed. They never signed anything and do not know whether they are obligated. The general rule is that debts are paid with the assets the person left, not with the family’s money.
Do the debts pass to the heirs?
They pass to the estate (sucesión), which is the set of assets, rights, and obligations left by the decedent (causante), that is, the deceased person. But the heir is liable for the debts only up to the value of the estate’s assets. If Don Jorge left a house worth ten million colones and debts of fifteen million, the creditors collect from what the assets bring in; the difference does not come out of the children’s pockets.
The same article distinguishes two situations, and the difference lies in who must prove what:
- If the heir accepted the inheritance “unconditionally” (pura y simplemente), it is up to the heir to show that the assets are not enough to pay.
- If the heir accepted it “with benefit of inventory” (a beneficio de inventario), that is, with an inventory of the assets, it is the creditors who must prove that there are other assets besides those inventoried.
If the inventory is not started or not completed within the legal deadline through the heir’s fault, the inheritance is deemed accepted unconditionally. In the probate proceedings (proceso sucesorio), the executor (albacea), who manages the estate, must file the inventory within fifteen days after accepting the position. What each one does is explained in this article.
How do creditors collect?
Within the probate proceedings. Ordinary creditors must file their claim in the proceedings, with a detailed statement of the amounts and the supporting documents. The claims filed are made known to the interested parties for five days. If no one objects, the court decides whether they exist, how much they amount to, and what priority they have; if there is an objection, it is heard in a separate procedure called an incidente.
Creditors with a mortgage or a pledge, whom the law calls secured creditors (separatistas), are not required to come forward, but only up to the value of their collateral. If a balance remains unpaid after the house or the car is auctioned, they must collect it within the probate proceedings, together with the other ordinary creditors.
Once recognized, the claims are paid. If necessary, the executor sells the assets chosen for that purpose, even for less than the appraisal when the circumstances justify it. If there is not enough for everyone, payment is made pro rata, that is, in proportion to each debt, unless the law gives one of them priority.
In what order are debts paid?
The Civil Code, in the chapter on the division of the estate and payment of creditors, sets these rules:
- Debts are paid as creditors come forward. But a creditor without a mortgage or pledge who is paid in the first six months of the probate proceedings must guarantee that they will return whatever corresponds to another creditor with an equal or better right who comes forward before those six months expire.
- Two years to come forward. A creditor who does not file a claim in the first two years cannot claim anything from the creditors who have already been paid. They can only pursue the legatees (legatarios), who are those who received a specific asset under a will, if no assets remain and two years have not passed since they received their legacy. This does not change the rights of the mortgage creditor.
- The executor is liable for distributing without setting aside funds. If the executor knew of a debt and handed over the assets without leaving enough to pay it, the executor is liable with their own assets.
- Debts first, inheritance second. Legacies are delivered only if the creditors remain secured by the rest of the assets, and the terms of the division must set aside what is needed for creditors’ claims still in dispute.
What remains is divided among the heirs. The steps of the proceedings are explained in this article.
What do I do if creditors call the family?
- Do not pay out of your own pocket under pressure. If you did not sign the debt, the creditor must collect from the estate’s assets.
- Ask about credit life insurance (seguro de saldo deudor). Many loans include it, and under it the insurer must pay the creditor the principal and interest the debtor left unpaid.
- Check whether you signed. If you signed as a co-borrower or as a guarantor, you are liable because of your own signature, not as an heir. A guarantor undertakes to pay if the debtor does not.
- Do not sign new documents that put the debt in your name: a contract binds whoever signs it.
- Ask the creditor to file the claim in the probate proceedings. If they have not been opened yet, anyone who shows a legitimate interest may open them.
Practical recommendations
- Make a list of debts and assets, with account statements, contracts, and property registry reports.
- Ask each creditor for the balance in writing and ask whether the loan had insurance.
- Make sure the inventory is filed on time. If it is not done through the heir’s fault, the inheritance is deemed accepted unconditionally.
- Do not distribute assets before paying known debts. An executor who does so without setting aside what is needed is personally liable.
Need help?
At Murillo y Guzmán we can review the deceased’s debts, check whether there was insurance covering them, and defend the family against collection demands that do not apply to them. Book a consultation.
This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice for any specific case. To discuss your situation, book a consultation.
Related insights
-
Inheritance
Inventory and Appraisal: How Do You Know What Makes Up the Estate and What It Is Worth?
Who prepares the estate inventory, how the value of each asset is set, and what to do if an heir believes an asset is missing or does not belong in...
-
Inheritance
Life Insurance, Pensions, and Savings: Are They Part of the Estate?
Life insurance with a beneficiary, survivor pensions, and accounts or certificates with named beneficiaries are not divided in the estate; other mo...
-
Inheritance
An Heir Lives Abroad or Cannot Be Found: Does Probate Come to a Halt?
If an heir lives abroad or cannot be found, probate goes on. How the heir is notified, who represents them, what happens to their share, and how to...
Comments
Loading comments…
Thank you. Your comment is awaiting review and will be published if it complies with the comment policy.