Ciudad Quesada, San Carlos, Costa Rica · Barrio San Martín (Gamonales), across from the EBAIS (public health clinic) Phone +506 2460-7226 [email protected]

Inheritance

I Think the Will Is Not Valid: When Can It Be Annulled?

When a will is void for lack of capacity, disqualified witnesses, or the notary's interest, whether a joint will is valid, and the deadline for filing suit.

Translated from the Spanish original. If there is any discrepancy between the two versions, the Spanish text prevails. Read the original in Spanish.

When the father’s probate is opened, a will turns up that leaves everything to his second wife. The children have doubts: he was ill when he signed it, and one of the witnesses was her sister. Can it be annulled? The law is very protective of a will’s form, but it requires evidence and sets a deadline. We explain the kinds of wills and how they are opened in this article.

Can a formal defect void it?

Yes. The Second Chamber of the Supreme Court (Sala Segunda) has held that a will is a solemn act and that its formalities are essential, so that omitting any of them makes it absolutely void. An open will is executed before a notary public (civil-law notary) and three witnesses, or two if the testator wrote it; it must be read aloud before the witnesses and signed by everyone, in a single continuous act. It can also be executed without a notary, before four witnesses if the testator wrote it or six if not, as we explain in this other publication.

The witnesses must be of legal age, able to read and write, and free of any disqualification. Disqualified are those who have an interest in the act and the spouse, siblings, ascendants, and descendants, up to the second degree of blood relationship or relationship by marriage, of the notary or of the persons making the will.

In a 2022 case, one of the witnesses was the sister of the female testator and the sister-in-law of the male testator. The Chamber upheld the annulment of the will and made clear that proving the family relationship is enough, without having to show that the witness had an interest. On the other hand, the fact that another witness was the executor’s wife did not void the will, because the executor received nothing under it.

On the other hand, a will is not void because it leaves an asset that did not belong to the testator. Only that provision is void, and the rest of the will remains valid. We explain it in this other publication.

What if the testator was not of sound mind?

People who are not of sound mind and minors under fifteen cannot make a will, and capacity is measured at the time the will is executed. But capacity is presumed, and proving otherwise is not easy.

In a 2025 case, the plaintiffs argued that the testator had suffered strokes. The Second Chamber rejected the claim: the strokes occurred nine months after the will, the expert report was prepared after his death on the basis of later tests, and a brief medical note about recent memory loss did not show that he was unable to decide about his property. The Chamber noted that the evidence must be so weighty that it leaves no room for doubt.

The notary who prepares the will may not receive anything under it, nor authorize acts in which the notary, the witnesses, or their relatives have an interest. In the same 2025 case, it was argued that the witnesses were the notary’s office colleagues, but it was proven that they worked for another attorney in the same building. That was not enough, and the burden of proving the interest fell on the party alleging it.

Is a joint will valid?

Yes. A joint will (testamento mancomunado) is one made by two or more people in the same act, such as spouses who name each other as heirs. The Civil Code allows it and lets each of them revoke their own provisions separately. In that same 2025 case, the Chamber added that no rule requires each person to make their declaration separately, and that using a format similar to that of other wills does not invalidate it if it reflects the wishes of those who sign it.

Is there a deadline to sue?

Yes. An action for absolute nullity is time-barred after ten years. According to the Second Chamber, the period runs from the testator’s death if the will was known, or from the publication of the notice (edicto) calling on interested parties if it was not. In that case, a son alleged that the signatures had been placed on blank pages and that the witnesses signed separately days later, but he sued fifteen years after his mother’s death, and the action was time-barred. While the validity of the will is being litigated, the probate proceeding is suspended.

Unworthiness to inherit (indignidad) is a different matter: it bars from inheriting anyone who, for example, made an attempt against the deceased, falsely accused them, abandoned them, or deceived them into disposing of their property. It must be declared by a judge, and the action is time-barred after four years of possession of the inheritance. In another 2025 case, the Second Chamber cautioned that the seriousness of the offenses can only be assessed after the evidence has been received.

Practical recommendations

  1. Request a copy of the will and check who signed as witnesses and how they are related to the testator and to the notary.
  2. Look for medical evidence from the date of the will, not from months later.
  3. Count the deadlines: ten years for nullity and four years of possession for unworthiness.
  4. Act as soon as probate is opened.

Need help?

At Murillo y Guzmán we can review the will, the available evidence, and the deadlines, and tell you whether it makes sense to sue for its annulment or for an heir’s unworthiness. Book a consultation.

This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice for any specific case. To discuss your situation, book a consultation.

All insights Share

Related insights

Comments

Loading comments…