Ciudad Quesada, San Carlos, Costa Rica · Barrio San Martín (Gamonales), across from the EBAIS (public health clinic) Phone +506 2460-7226 [email protected]

Inheritance

Can Someone Who Abused or Abandoned the Deceased Be Left Without an Inheritance?

Which conduct bars inheriting under the Costa Rican Civil Code, who must ask the court, the deadline, and what happens with income and in femicide cases.

Translated from the Spanish original. If there is any discrepancy between the two versions, the Spanish text prevails. Read the original in Spanish.

Doña Marta spent her last three years bedridden. One of her daughters cared for her. Her son did not visit her or help with expenses, even though he had the means to do so. She died without a will, and now he is claiming his share of the house. The law does not punish every family quarrel, but it does allow someone who engaged in certain serious conduct to be left out of the inheritance. This is called unworthiness to inherit (indignidad).

What conduct bars someone from inheriting?

The Civil Code (Código Civil), as amended in 2019, lists seven grounds. They apply whether or not there is a will, and they refer to the decedent (causante), the deceased person whose estate is being divided:

  • Attacking their life or physical integrity. Killing or attempting to kill the decedent, or the decedent’s parents, spouse, or children; injuring them; physically or sexually assaulting them; or committing a serious offense against them, their honor, or their memory. The conduct must be duly proven.
  • Falsely accusing them. Reporting the decedent for a crime they did not commit, or giving false testimony against them in a criminal case.
  • Failing as a guardian. A relative called to serve as the decedent’s guardian (tutor) who, through their own fault, did not serve, was removed for mismanagement, or was found guilty of fraud when rendering accounts.
  • Refusing them support. Refusing to provide support (alimentos) while legally obligated to do so. For example, children owe support to their parents.
  • Abandoning them. Abandoning the decedent or failing to give them dignified treatment, assistance, and companionship, when able to do so, while the decedent could not care for themselves because of an illness, a disability, being a minor, or being an older adult.
  • Tampering with the will. Using fraud or force to prevent the decedent from making or revoking a will, hiding or destroying the will, or forcing the decedent to make one.
  • Taking advantage of them. Using deceit, abuse of power, or coercion, or exploiting the decedent’s vulnerability, to induce them to dispose of their property or money to their own detriment or that of their direct dependents.

Estrangement or a bad relationship, by themselves, are not on that list. In Doña Marta’s case, what would have to be proven is abandonment: that she could not care for herself and that her son, while able to help her, did not.

Is it enough that the family knows?

No. Unworthiness only takes effect if a court declares it, at the request of an interested party, such as another heir who would receive more if the unworthy heir is left out. It is litigated in a separate lawsuit, and while the question of who is an heir is being decided, the probate proceedings (proceso sucesorio) are suspended. It should not be confused with the annulment of a will, which we explain in this article.

There are two time limits:

  • Four years. The claim is time-barred four years after the unworthy heir takes possession of the inheritance or of the legacy, which is the specific asset someone receives under a will.
  • Death of the unworthy heir. If the heir dies before anyone files the lawsuit, it can no longer be brought against that heir’s own heirs.

For an extreme case there is a special rule: the probate proceedings are suspended with respect to an heir who has been formally charged (imputado) in the investigation into the femicide of the decedent.

What did the Second Chamber say in 2025?

In a 2025 case, a son, on his own behalf and as executor (albacea) of his father’s estate, asked that his grandmother, the deceased’s mother, who had been declared an heir, be declared unworthy for serious offenses against his father and against him. The trial court dismissed the lawsuit before receiving the evidence, stating that none of the facts fit the grounds set by law. The Second Chamber of the Supreme Court (Sala Segunda) set that judgment aside and ordered the case to proceed.

The Chamber explained that the seriousness of an offense can only be weighed after all the evidence has been received. It added that the lawsuit still made sense even though an asset had been removed from the estate, because unworthiness eliminates the very status of heir. The Chamber did not decide whether the grandmother was unworthy: that was left for the trial.

What if the deceased forgave them?

If the testator knew of the ground for unworthiness when making the will, or learned of it later and did not change the will when able to do so, the heir is rehabilitated, meaning they regain the right to inherit.

What happens if the court declares the heir unworthy?

The excluded person must return all the fruits, meaning income such as rent or crops, received since the estate was opened. The estate is opened upon death.

Their share is not lost, but no one gets to choose where it goes. The law applies two rules, always in this order:

  1. First, representation (representación). In an estate without a will, the unworthy heir’s children may take their place and receive the share that the unworthy heir would have received. The law allows this only in favor of the descendants of the deceased and the deceased’s nephews and nieces. In practice, this happens when the unworthy heir is a child of the deceased, in which case the grandchildren step in, or a sibling of the deceased, in which case the nephews and nieces step in.
  2. Then, the right of accretion (derecho de acrecer). Only if no one can take their place is their share added to the shares of the other heirs, who divide it among themselves. This happens, for example, when the unworthy heir has no children, or when the unworthy heir is the father, mother, spouse, or cohabiting partner of the deceased: their relatives are not descendants or nephews or nieces of the deceased.

The two rules do not contradict each other: the second applies only when the first does not.

An example. Suppose doña Marta’s only heirs are her two children, and the court declares the son who abandoned her unworthy. If he has two children, those grandchildren of doña Marta step into his place and divide his half: one quarter of the inheritance each. The daughter who cared for her keeps her half. If the unworthy son has no children, no one can take his place: his half is added to his sister’s, and she receives the entire inheritance.

Under a will, the rule is different. The provision in favor of the unworthy heir lapses, and their share goes to the other heirs named in the will, unless the testator provided otherwise. If no other heirs remain under the will, that share is distributed as if there were no will.

The same rules apply when an heir renounces, and we explain them with more examples in this other publication. Who inherits and in what order is explained in this article.

Practical recommendations

  1. Gather the evidence now: criminal complaints, judgments, medical records, messages, and people who witnessed the abandonment or the assault.
  2. Count the four years from the date the other heir took possession of the inheritance.
  3. Check whether there is a will and its date. If the deceased knew of the conduct and did not change the will, the heir is rehabilitated.
  4. Do not leave them out on your own. Until there is a judgment declaring unworthiness, that person is still an heir.

Need help?

At Murillo y Guzmán we can review the available evidence, tell you whether the conduct fits any ground for unworthiness, and file the lawsuit in time. Book a consultation.

This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice for any specific case. To discuss your situation, book a consultation.

All insights Share

Related insights

Comments

Loading comments…