Someone Is Taking the Deceased's Belongings: How Can They Be Protected?
What a court can order so that the money, livestock, or vehicles of a deceased person do not disappear, before or during probate proceedings in Costa Rica.
Translated from the Spanish original. If there is any discrepancy between the two versions, the Spanish text prevails. Read the original in Spanish.
Don Rafael, a cattle rancher from Pital, has died. Two weeks after the funeral, one of his sons began selling steers and took the pickup truck and the chainsaw from the farm. The other siblings have not yet opened probate and fear that, by the time they do, there will be nothing left to divide. The law has a tool for cases like this: the securing of assets (aseguramiento de bienes).
What can the court order?
The Civil Procedure Code allows the assets of the deceased, whom the law calls the decedent (causante), to be secured before probate proceedings (proceso sucesorio) are opened or while they are underway. The court may take all necessary measures. Among them:
- Start with what is easily lost. The law requires that assets that can easily be taken be secured first, such as money, animals, vehicles, or tools.
- Notify banks and offices. Notices may be sent to banks and to public and private offices to freeze the assets, for example an account or a certificate of deposit.
- Place the assets in responsible hands. Once secured, they are handed over to the executor (albacea), the person who manages the estate, or to a custodian (depositario) appointed by the court until the executor accepts the position.
- Call the police in an emergency. The police may place seals on the assets and guard them, and must notify the court as soon as possible so that it can order them secured.
In addition, the court may issue, even on its own initiative, any other precautionary measure (medida cautelar) needed to preserve the estate. A precautionary measure is a temporary order to prevent harm while the matter is resolved.
How is it requested and what must be shown?
It is requested by someone with a legitimate interest in the estate, such as a child or the spouse. The court weighs three things: that there is a danger of loss or harm, that the request appears to be well founded, and that the measure is proportionate. In practice, it is advisable to bring:
- Proof of death. In an emergency, the court may accept it through any suitable means, although before declaring the heirs it must be fully proven.
- Proof that the assets belonged to the deceased, such as certificates from the National Registry (Registro Nacional), account statements, or purchase documents.
- A specific explanation of the risk: what is being taken, by whom, and since when.
What cannot be secured?
The securing of assets protects only the decedent’s assets. In a 2020 case, the Agrarian Court (Tribunal Agrario) upheld the rejection of a request by a widower to secure the buildings put up on two plots of land from the Rural Development Institute (INDER). He argued that they were marital property, but the plots were already registered in the name of one of the heirs. The Court explained that buildings are part of the land, and that this procedure cannot be used to secure assets registered in another person’s name, even if their title is being challenged in another lawsuit. Recovering them requires filing the appropriate lawsuit, and that is the executor’s role, since the executor represents the estate both in and out of court.
There are two other limits. If real property has been in someone else’s hands for a long time with the consent of the deceased and a lawsuit is needed to recover it, it is not handed over to the executor. And precautionary measures are not issued against situations that the person requesting them accepted for a long time, unless that person explains why they were not requested earlier.
Can a notary public do it?
No. Probate before a notary public (civil-law notary) works when all the heirs agree, as we explain in this article. The Notarial Code (Código Notarial) does not include the securing of assets among the matters that notaries public may handle, and the Guidelines for the Practice and Oversight of Notarial Services (Lineamientos para el ejercicio y control del servicio notarial) expressly reserve it for the courts. In addition, if a dispute arises, the notary public must stop and send the file to the court. When someone is taking the assets, the path is the court.
What changes once there is an executor?
Upon accepting the position, the executor takes possession of the assets without any further formality. If someone prevents the executor from taking them, the executor may ask the court to place them in possession. From then on, the executor manages the assets and must account for that management. We explain exactly what an executor does in this article, and the steps of probate in court in this other one.
Practical recommendations
- Act quickly. The more time passes, the harder it will be to prove what there was and where it is.
- Make a list of the assets with supporting evidence: Registry certificates, account statements, photos, receipts, and the names of witnesses.
- If the situation is urgent, go to the police and ask that the court be informed.
- If you requested the securing of assets before probate, open probate as soon as possible, so that an executor is appointed and the assets come under the executor’s management.
Need help?
At Murillo y Guzmán we can request that the assets be secured, open probate, and follow up on the measures the court orders. Book a consultation.
This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice for any specific case. To discuss your situation, book a consultation.
Related insights
-
Inheritance
An Heir Lives Abroad or Cannot Be Found: Does Probate Come to a Halt?
If an heir lives abroad or cannot be found, probate goes on. How the heir is notified, who represents them, what happens to their share, and how to...
-
Inheritance
Both Parents Have Died: Can Their Estates Be Settled in a Single Proceeding?
Both parents' estates can be settled together if they have the same heirs or shared property. When it is allowed and what happens if they died on t...
-
Inheritance
Sealed Will: How Is It Made and How Does It Differ From an Open Will?
A sealed will keeps what you provide secret until your death. How it is executed before a notary public, its risks, and how it compares to an open ...
Comments
Loading comments…
Thank you. Your comment is awaiting review and will be published if it complies with the comment policy.