Ciudad Quesada, San Carlos, Costa Rica · Barrio San Martín (Gamonales), across from the EBAIS (public health clinic) Phone +506 2460-7226 [email protected]

InheritanceFamily

I Was Left Out of the Will: Do I Have Any Rights?

In Costa Rica a person may leave a will freely, but must ensure support for minor or disabled children, parents, and spouse. What can and cannot be claimed.

Translated from the Spanish original. If there is any discrepancy between the two versions, the Spanish text prevails. Read the original in Spanish.

When reading her father’s will, Carolina discovers that everything went to her older brother. She is 35, has a job, and always thought the law guaranteed her a share as his daughter. In Costa Rica it does not. But there are people who, even if the will leaves them out, can still claim something.

Can a person leave everything to whomever he or she wants?

Almost. The Civil Code (Código Civil) allows the person making a will to dispose freely of his or her assets, on one condition: certain support (alimentos) must be ensured. Our Code does not reserve a fixed portion of the estate for children or the spouse, what other countries call a “forced share” (legítima). The Constitutional Chamber of the Supreme Court (Sala Constitucional) explained this in 2004: that rule does not create “a forced inheritance,” but a way of protecting the right to support of the closest relatives.

In the language of the law, support is not just food. It includes sustenance, housing, clothing, medical care, transportation, and, for minors and persons with disabilities, education and training, according to the means of the person who must provide it and the standard of living to which the recipient was accustomed.

Who can claim support?

The Civil Code requires the testator to ensure:

  • Support for his or her minor children, until they reach the age of majority.
  • Support for his or her children with a disability that prevents them from taking care of themselves, for their entire lives.
  • The maintenance of his or her parents, for as long as they need it.
  • The maintenance of his or her spouse, for as long as he or she needs it.

There is a limit: if, when the testator dies, those persons have sufficient assets, the testator was not required to leave them support. And the list is closed: an adult child without a disability, a sibling, or a grandchild is not on it.

What happens if the will did not take them into account?

The will is not annulled for that reason. What changes is what the heir receives: the heir keeps only what is left after setting aside, based on an expert assessment, an amount sufficient to ensure that person’s support. In other words, the claim is not for a share of the estate, but for what is needed for support, and only for as long as the right lasts: until the age of majority, for life, or for as long as it is needed.

How is it claimed?

Within testate probate proceedings (proceso sucesorio testamentario), which is where the Constitutional Chamber placed this protection in that 2004 ruling. When probate is opened, the court publishes a notice (edicto) giving heirs and interested parties fifteen days to come forward and assert their rights.

Whoever makes the claim must prove the facts on which it is based: the family relationship, the need, and, where applicable, the disability. If the person entitled to support is a minor, he or she acts through a representative, and probate cannot be handled before a notary public (civil-law notary).

What cannot be claimed?

  • A share equal to that of one’s siblings merely for being a child. Without a forced share, that right does not exist.
  • That the distribution is unfair. The law respects the testator’s wishes as long as the support obligation is met.

There are two different situations that do open other doors. If the will does not dispose of all the assets, or if it lapses or is annulled, the part left undisposed of passes to the heirs designated by law; we explain who inherits in that case in this article. And if you suspect that the will is not valid, because of its form or because the testator was not in a condition to make it, read this other publication.

Practical recommendations

  1. Get a copy of the will and check whether it disposes of all the assets. We explain how to find out whether one exists in this article.
  2. Check whether you fall under any of the cases the law protects: a minor child, a child with a disability, a father, mother, or spouse who needs maintenance.
  3. Gather evidence of need: expenses, income, and, if applicable, medical reports.
  4. Come forward in probate as soon as the notice is published.

Need help?

At Murillo y Guzmán we can review the will, tell you whether you are entitled to claim support or whether it is worth challenging its validity, and represent you in probate. Book a consultation.

This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice for any specific case. To discuss your situation, book a consultation.

All insights Share

Related insights

Comments

Loading comments…