Ciudad Quesada, San Carlos, Costa Rica · Barrio San Martín (Gamonales), across from the EBAIS (public health clinic) Phone +506 2460-7226 [email protected]

Proposed LegislationTrafficProperty Registry

The Judge Ordered the Vehicle Seized, but No One Stops It: Our Proposed Law

Our proposed law seeks to ensure that court orders to seize vehicles are carried out, with a public registry searchable by plate and licensed agents.

Translated from the Spanish original. If there is any discrepancy between the two versions, the Spanish text prevails. Read the original in Spanish.

A person won a collection case, and the court issued a seizure order (orden de captura) for the vehicle pledged as collateral. A mother is owed overdue child support, and the judge ordered the debtor’s car to be seized. In both cases the official order reached the Traffic Police (Policía de Tránsito), but months go by and the vehicle is still on the road. At Murillo y Guzmán we drafted a proposed law with a different system so that these orders are carried out, and we plan to propose it to the Legislative Assembly (Asamblea Legislativa). It is not yet a bill under consideration or a law in force: here we explain what problem it seeks to solve and what it proposes.

What problem does it seek to solve?

Today the court issues a paper order (oficio) that the interested party must take to the General Directorate of the Traffic Police. There it piles up with thousands of orders that a police force devoted to road safety, without enough staff, tow trucks, or impound lots, cannot carry out. Only a fraction are executed, almost always by chance, when the vehicle is stopped at a routine checkpoint.

The proposal points out that no law regulates how a vehicle subject to a court order is located, stopped, and moved. The Traffic Law (Ley de Tránsito) allows vehicles to be taken off the road, but for traffic-related reasons; none of the eleven it lists is a court order. In the text’s view, this empties the right to prompt and complete justice, makes credit more expensive, and leaves small creditors and people awaiting child support with no way out. It adds a road safety risk: the hidden vehicle often circulates without a technical inspection, without mandatory insurance, and without the annual registration fee (marchamo).

What does it propose?

The bill rests on three measures.

  • A public registry of orders. A National Registry of Vehicle Seizure Orders (Registro Nacional de Órdenes de Aprehensión Vehicular) would be created within the Movable Property Registry (Registro de Bienes Muebles) of the National Registry (Registro Nacional). The court would record the order electronically once it becomes final, and anyone could look it up free of charge by plate or chassis number. It would show only data about the vehicle and the order: it would be prohibited to include the name, ID number, or amount of the debt, to search by person, or to use the information to evaluate credit. Anyone buying a used car would know whether an order weighs on it.
  • Licensed seizure agents. Companies accredited by the Road Safety Council (Consejo de Seguridad Vial, Cosevi), with a financial guarantee, a tow truck, and an impound lot, would carry out the order on the court’s instructions. They could act only on public roads and in parking areas open to the public, never in homes, garages, yards, or farms. The vehicle would go to an impound lot at the judge’s disposal, never to the creditor.
  • Checkpoints. Vehicle inspection centers would have to check the registry when each vehicle arrives and notify the authorities; the vehicle could be held there for a maximum of three hours, but people would be free to leave. In addition, while the order is in force the marchamo certificate would not be issued, although taxes and insurance could still be paid.

What safeguards would the vehicle’s owner have?

The text prohibits agents from carrying weapons, using violence, or detaining anyone, and requires them to stop the procedure at any objection. The entire operation would have to be recorded on video; without the recording, the procedure would be void. Seizure would not be allowed with people inside, with a patient who needs medical care, or if it is the only adapted vehicle of a person with a disability, among other cases.

The owner would be notified within twenty-four hours and could object within three business days. If the owner pays, reaches an arrangement, or posts a guarantee, the vehicle would be returned within twenty-four hours. If the seizure was improper, the owner would receive compensation of one base salary (salario base) for each day without the vehicle. Fees would be capped by decree. And the bill does not punish the debtor for owing: the crimes it creates target the agent who abuses the system.

What stage is it at?

The text is complete, and the firm plans to propose it to the Legislative Assembly. It has not yet been filed, so it does not have a legislative file number. It would amend the Traffic Law, the Civil Procedure Code (Código Procesal Civil), and the Secured Transactions Law (Ley de Garantías Mobiliarias), and, because it affects the functioning of the Judiciary, the Supreme Court of Justice (Corte Suprema de Justicia) would have to be consulted. Until it is approved, none of this applies, and its content may change.

Practical recommendations

  1. Today, orders are still carried out through the Traffic Police. If you are a creditor, follow up on the paper order.
  2. Before buying a used vehicle, request a title search (estudio registral). Check liens and annotations; the proposed registry of orders does not yet exist.
  3. If an order weighs on your vehicle, seek an arrangement within the case. Hiding the vehicle does not stop the debt.
  4. Follow this proposal. We will report here when it is submitted to the Legislative Assembly.

Need help?

Vehicle seizure orders arise in collection cases, secured-loan foreclosures, and child support cases, and each one has its own procedure. At Murillo y Guzmán we can review your case file and explain what options you have today. Book a consultation.

This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice for any specific case. To discuss your situation, book a consultation.

All insights Share

Related insights

Comments

Loading comments…