Access to Public InformationConstitutional
When Can Public Information Be Denied to Me? The Limits the Law Allows and the Abuses It Forbids
Only the Constitution, a treaty or a statute can limit access to public information. What a denial must say and which abuses are forbidden.
Translated from the Spanish original. If there is any discrepancy between the two versions, the Spanish text prevails. Read the original in Spanish.
In this article9 sections
- Who can decide that information will not be released?
- What limits exist?
- Is it enough that a statute exists?
- When did the Constitutional Chamber accept a denial, and when did it reject one?
- What abuses does the regulation forbid?
- If only part of it is protected, can they deny me everything?
- What must the denial say?
- Practical recommendations
- Need help?
A woman asked her municipality for a copy of the technical report and the contract under which a municipal lot next to her house was filled in. Ten business days later she got a one-line email: “The requested information is confidential.” It did not say why, under what legal provision, or whether any part could be released. That answer does not comply with the Framework Law on Access to Public Information (Ley Marco de Acceso a la Información Pública). An institution may deny information in certain cases, but only when the Constitution, a treaty or a statute allows it, and it must explain why in writing and release everything not protected.
We explain which information is presumed public in the article on what information you can request, and how to request it in this other publication on how to request information from a public institution.
Who can decide that information will not be released?
Only the Political Constitution, an international treaty approved by the Legislative Assembly or a statute can limit access to public information. This is the statutory reserve (reserva de ley): restricting a fundamental right is up to the Legislative Assembly, not the institution holding the information.
So an executive decree, a regulation, a circular, a board resolution or an internal policy cannot create a limit on its own. The law’s regulation says so expressly for institutions’ resolutions or declarations: in a specific case they may apply a ground for confidentiality already in the Constitution or a statute, but they cannot create new categories of restricted information.
What limits exist?
The regulation lists, among others, these:
- personal data protected by law, especially sensitive data, such as medical information (not every piece of personal data is protected: a public official’s gross salary is public);
- private information;
- state secrets;
- professional, commercial, industrial, fiscal (tax), economic, banking and fiduciary secrecy.
That list is not a blank check: each limit exists only if the Constitution, a treaty or a statute establishes it, and the regulation itself closes the list with “the other restrictions legitimately established by law.” Special statutes set other limits, such as these two:
- The identity of anyone who reports an act of corruption is confidential, even after the complaint has been dealt with.
- Investigations by internal audit units, by the Administration and by the Office of the Comptroller General of the Republic (Contraloría General de la República) that may lead to an administrative proceeding are confidential, even for the complainant and the person complained against, while the report is being prepared. Afterwards, and until the proceeding ends, only the parties may see the file.
Personal data, commercial, banking and tax secrecy, and state secrets will each have their own article in this series.
Is it enough that a statute exists?
No. Even if a statute protects the information, the institution must apply it restrictively, reasonably and proportionately, through a reasoned decision. Restrictively means not stretching the limit beyond its text, because the general rule is access.
The regulation also sets five conditions for denying information as confidential:
- An express legal provision. The institution must identify the specific statute that protects that information.
- A justification by the competent authority. Whoever has the power to deny it must explain why that statute applies to what you requested.
- Only what is strictly necessary. If the problem lies in one piece of data, that piece of data is withheld, not the entire file.
- Time limits, where applicable. Some limits last only while their justifying reason exists, such as the audit investigations above. When that reason disappears, so does that ground for denial, although another may remain, such as the complainant’s identity.
- Real, current and substantial harm. The institution must show that releasing the information would cause specific, present and significant harm to the public interest the statute protects. A hypothetical risk is not enough.
The institution, not you, must show these conditions are met. And among several ways of protecting that interest, it must choose the one that restricts access least.
The regulation makes no exceptions: these conditions also apply when a statute declares something specific confidential, such as the identity of someone who reports corruption. There too, the institution must explain why what you requested falls into that category, why redacting part of it is not enough and what harm releasing it would cause.
When did the Constitutional Chamber accept a denial, and when did it reject one?
In two cases before the Constitutional Chamber of the Supreme Court (Sala Constitucional), another legal limit was invoked: the provision that reserves the investigation stage of a criminal proceeding to the parties.
In a 2022 case, journalists had asked the Office of the Chief Public Prosecutor (Fiscalía General) for information on several criminal complaints: the status of the investigations, the steps taken and who was under investigation. The prosecutor’s office refused based on that provision and its own organic law, which forbids it to disclose the secrecy of investigations. By a majority, the Chamber found the denial reasonable, because the prosecutor’s office relied on legal limits and explained why; it ordered it only to answer whether it had received a certain complaint. But it warned that, in each case, the authority must assess whether releasing the requested information would truly affect the presumption of innocence, privacy or safety of those involved, or endanger the investigation. That case predates the law and its regulation.
In a 2026 case, by contrast, a management office of the Costa Rican Social Security Fund (Caja Costarricense de Seguro Social) invoked that same provision to withhold the supporting files for certain administrative reports. The Chamber reminded it that a criminal investigation does not, by itself, justify denying all access, unless it is shown concretely and specifically that disclosure really and currently compromises constitutionally protected interests, and that was not shown. The Chamber ordered all the information released, except any subject to a specific and reasoned legal restriction.
The difference: the first request sought information from the criminal investigation itself, and the prosecutor’s office explained the legal limit; the second sought administrative documents, and the criminal case was used as a general label, without showing any concrete harm.
What abuses does the regulation forbid?
The regulation strictly forbids using grounds for confidentiality to hide information of public interest, limit accountability, cover up irregularities or restrict citizens’ oversight of public functions. And the Law against Corruption and Illicit Enrichment in Public Service (Ley contra la Corrupción y el Enriquecimiento Ilícito en la Función Pública) declares information on the handling of public money, from when it comes in until it is spent, to be of public interest. A contract, an invoice or payment for a trip does not become secret because it shows an error or irregularity. If an audit is investigating them, what is confidential is that investigation’s file, not those documents.
These answers, on their own, are not enough:
- “It is confidential,” without saying which statute provides so.
- “It is for internal use” or “it is for the exclusive use of this office.” In 2025, the Chamber rejected a ministry’s declaration that all the documentation of a job competition was “confidential and for the exclusive use” of one of its offices, as we described in the article on the administrative file.
Nor is an ambiguous or incomplete answer acceptable without justifying what is missing. The law expressly lists this among the situations that justify an amparo action (recurso de amparo).
If only part of it is protected, can they deny me everything?
No. If the information is partly public and partly confidential, or contains sensitive data, the institution must give you the public part and redact only what is protected, clearly explaining why. For example, if the file of a public-sector job competition includes a candidate’s medical history or address, that data is redacted and the rest is released. In the 2025 competition case, the Chamber ordered the documentation released while safeguarding the sensitive data.
What must the denial say?
Every denial, total or partial, must:
- be in writing and served on you within the institution’s time to respond: ten business days, or the extension it notified you of in time;
- state the limit and the legal provision on which it relies;
- explain why that limit applies to what you requested;
- specify which part of the information is being restricted;
- state which remedies are available, before which authority they are filed and within what time limit.
If the denial does not say which legal provision it relies on or why it applies to your request, you can challenge it before the institution itself or the Constitutional Chamber; each route will have its own article in this series. But winning does not make public what a statute does protect: the institution will have to release the rest and properly explain why it withholds that part.
Practical recommendations
- Always ask for the denial in writing. If you are told orally or by phone, ask for it to be sent through the channel given in your request.
- Look for the legal provision behind the denial. It must be the Constitution, a treaty or a statute. If the answer cites only a regulation, a circular or an internal resolution, or cites no provision at all, the denial is poorly grounded, although that does not prove the information is public.
- Ask for what is not protected. If the document may contain other people’s protected data, say in your request that you accept it with only that data redacted.
- If the restriction is temporary, ask how long it lasts, and request the information again once it ends.
- Challenge it promptly. To challenge a denial before the institution, the regulation gives ten business days; the General Law of Public Administration (Ley General de la Administración Pública), three; and the Municipal Code (Código Municipal), five for municipalities. The prudent course is to file within three business days of being served, or five for a municipality, even if the denial says otherwise or nothing; if that time has passed, file anyway before the ten days are up. For an amparo action you do not need to challenge the denial first, but do not let more than two months go by after the denial.
Need help?
If an institution denied you information, in whole or in part, at Murillo y Guzmán we can review the response, check whether the limit it invokes is in a statute and prepare the appropriate challenge. Book a consultation.
This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice for any specific case. To discuss your situation, book a consultation.
Related insights
-
Access to Public Information
What Every Public Institution Must Publish on Its Website Without Being Asked
Payrolls, budgets, minutes and purchases: what the law requires every Costa Rican public institution to post on its website, and what to do if it i...
-
Access to Public Information
Who Can I Ask for Information? Institutions, State Companies, Political Parties and Private Entities Handling Public Funds
Institutions, state companies, political parties and private entities with public funds must provide information. Who is left out and where to turn...
-
Access to Public Information
The Public Information Access Law Now Has a Regulation: What Changes for You?
Costa Rica's public information access law now has a regulation. What changes when you request data, what institutions must do and what you can dem...
Comments
Loading comments…
Thank you. Your comment is awaiting review and will be published if it complies with the comment policy.