AdministrativeAccess to Public InformationConstitutional
I'm a Party to an Administrative Proceeding: What Can I See in the File?
If you are a party to a proceeding, you can review and copy your file. Which documents can be withheld, whether your attorney needs a power, and how to object.
Translated from the Spanish original. If there is any discrepancy between the two versions, the Spanish text prevails. Read the original in Spanish.
In this article9 sections
- What is the file, and who is a party?
- What can I do with the file if I am a party?
- Does my attorney need a power of attorney to see the file?
- Which documents can be withheld from me?
- What if I am not a party?
- What happens in job competitions and public procurement?
- What do I do if I am not allowed to see the file?
- Practical recommendations
- Need help?
A municipality notifies a shopkeeper that it has opened proceedings to revoke his business license over neighbors’ complaints, and summons him to a hearing. Beforehand, he wants to read the complaints, see the photos and review the inspector’s report. His attorney asks for copies and is told the file is confidential and off-limits without the client’s power of attorney. Put that way, neither answer is correct. A party has a broad right to know the file’s contents, under its own rules, distinct from those governing public-information requests.
What is the file, and who is a party?
The file (expediente) is the set of documents, paper or digital, the institution must gather to make its decision: the application or complaint that started the proceeding, the reports, the evidence, the records of the hearings and the rulings.
A party is anyone with a right or legitimate interest the final decision may affect or satisfy: for example, a permit applicant, the shopkeeper facing license revocation, or a public employee facing disciplinary proceedings.
What can I do with the file if I am a party?
The General Public Administration Act (Ley General de la Administración Pública) gives you, your representatives and any attorney the right, at any stage of the proceeding, to examine, read and copy any document in the file, subject to the exceptions below, and to request certified copies. You may argue about what you find before the final decision. You bear the cost of copies and certifications.
The Constitutional Chamber of the Supreme Court (Sala Constitucional) considers this access part of due process, especially when someone is accused of acts that may lead to a penalty. If being denied the file leaves you defenseless, whatever is decided afterwards may be annulled.
Does my attorney need a power of attorney to see the file?
No. The law says “any attorney,” and the Constitutional Chamber has applied it that way. In 2017, an institution required an attorney to produce a power of attorney from his client before giving him certified copies of a file he needed as evidence in a lawsuit. The Chamber granted the amparo action (recurso de amparo): requiring that authorization violates the law and the right to information.
Still, an attorney without a power of attorney can see and copy the file but cannot file briefs or appeals for you; that requires a power of attorney, which can be a letter you sign and that same attorney authenticates. The institution must protect personal or sensitive information in the file unless the person it concerns authorizes full access, and may hand over copies with that data redacted. And while an investigation by the Office of the Comptroller General of the Republic (Contraloría General de la República) is under way, the attorney must be accredited as defense counsel or authorized by the interested party, and the special confidentiality rules explained below also apply.
A non-attorney reviewing the file for you also needs a power of attorney; a letter like that one, authenticated by an attorney, is enough.
Which documents can be withheld from me?
Only those the law excludes, document by document: those whose disclosure could compromise state secrets or the other party’s confidential information, or that would give the requester an undue advantage or a chance to unlawfully harm the institution, the other party or third parties. Unless proven otherwise, this is presumed of draft rulings and, until delivered, reports prepared for an advisory body and that body’s opinions. Examples: an unsigned draft ruling, or trade secrets submitted by a company competing with you in the same proceeding.
Three rules narrow those exceptions:
- The refusal must be explained. A decision denying access must state sufficient reasons.
- A document is withheld, not the entire file. The law speaks of documents, and the Constitutional Chamber has required institutions to hand over the whole file except what is truly confidential.
- Protected material can be redacted. In the attorney’s case above and in a job competition case discussed below, the Chamber ordered the information delivered with sensitive data protected, rather than denied.
There are also two special confidentiality rules. If the proceeding arises from a corruption complaint or an investigation by the internal audit unit, the institution itself or the Comptroller General’s Office, the Act against Corruption and Illicit Enrichment in the Public Service (Ley contra la Corrupción y el Enriquecimiento Ilícito en la Función Pública) protects the complainant’s identity and any information revealing it: it stays secret, even from the accused and after the matter closes. The preliminary investigation is also confidential, even for the complainant and the accused, while the report is prepared; once it is served, and until the final decision, only the parties may see the file’s documents and evidence.
What if I am not a party?
The Constitutional Chamber distinguishes access from within the proceeding, which belongs to the parties and is governed by the General Public Administration Act, from access from outside, which anyone has to learn about matters of public interest, governed by the Framework Law on Access to Public Information (Ley Marco de Acceso a la Información Pública): you need not explain why you want the information. We explain the steps and deadlines in this publication on how to request public information.
The difference lies in what each can see. A third party may request, say, the file of a concession in the maritime-terrestrial zone (zona marítimo terrestre), because it concerns public property. But not the protected personal data of those involved, such as sensitive or restricted-access data: the institution must provide the rest with that data redacted, unless a law makes the entire file confidential. A party, by contrast, can see the evidence used against them and, in general, every document, save the exceptions above.
What happens in job competitions and public procurement?
In 2025, a Ministry of Public Security employee who had taken part in an internal job competition asked for the competition’s documentation, and the ministry refused, calling it confidential. The employee filed an amparo petition and the Constitutional Chamber ruled in his favor: it ordered the ministry to give it to him, with sensitive data protected. As a rule, information on competitions to fill public positions, including on the candidates, is public; only sensitive or restricted-access personal data are confidential. Because the employee had taken part, he was exercising access from within and was entitled to the entire file except what was truly confidential.
Public procurement is similar: procurement acts are available to participants and any interested person, except legally protected information the institution declares confidential by reasoned decision, such as certain bid data.
What do I do if I am not allowed to see the file?
Ask for the refusal in writing, with its reasons. It can be challenged with a motion for reconsideration (revocatoria), decided by the body that denied access, and, if that body is not the head of the institution, with an appeal (apelación), decided by the head. Both are filed with the body conducting the proceeding, which may decide the reconsideration along with the final decision. Since the refusal is not the final decision, the General Public Administration Act allows only twenty-four hours from notice to challenge it. Special rules on challenges apply in areas such as personnel matters, taxes and public procurement, and in municipalities: the Municipal Code (Código Municipal) allows five business days (días hábiles) to challenge and permits appealing the mayor’s office’s decisions to the Contentious-Administrative Court (Tribunal Contencioso Administrativo). Check which remedy and deadline the notice indicates and, if in doubt, file as soon as possible, the same day if you can.
The access law’s regulation sets a different deadline, ten business days, to challenge refusals of public-information requests, those filed as any member of the public rather than as a party. Even then, it is prudent to object within three business days after notice, as we explain in the article on what changes with the regulation.
The General Public Administration Act also treats as force majeure any refusal or obstacle the institution puts in the way of your examining the file, except as to excluded documents. If it made you miss a deadline, you can ask for it to be restored: you get back the time you had left when the refusal occurred. Ask within eight business days after the obstacle disappears and, at the same time, do what you could not do. Asking does not halt the proceeding: keep attending summonses and meeting deadlines.
Finally, you can file an amparo action without first exhausting administrative remedies, as in the cases of the attorney without a power of attorney and the job competition. But the outcome is not guaranteed. In 2005 the Chamber said parties’ access also enjoys constitutional protection; in other rulings, however, it has insisted it is governed by the General Public Administration Act. Even if you plan to go to the Chamber, do not let the administrative challenge deadline lapse: filing it does not bar a later amparo action. We explain amparo in this publication on amparo and habeas corpus.
Practical recommendations
- Review the file as soon as you are notified, not the day before the hearing.
- Request a copy or a certified copy of what you will use in your defense or in a lawsuit.
- If you send someone else, give them backing. An attorney needs a power of attorney to file challenges on your behalf; anyone else needs one even to see the file. If the attorney must see your sensitive data, express authorization avoids disputes.
- Demand the reason for any refusal in writing. It must refer to specific documents, not to the entire file.
- Act immediately if you are refused. Depending on the proceeding, the challenge deadline may expire in twenty-four hours. If the refusal made you miss a deadline, ask for it to be restored.
Need help?
If an institution denies or delays your access to a file in a proceeding to which you are a party, it is best to act right away. At Murillo y Guzmán we can review the file with you and prepare the appropriate challenge. Book a consultation.
This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice for any specific case. To discuss your situation, book a consultation.
Related insights
-
Access to Public Information
The Public Information Access Law Now Has a Regulation: What Changes for You?
Costa Rica's public information access law now has a regulation. What changes when you request data, what institutions must do and what you can dem...
-
Administrative
I Know of Corruption in a Public Institution: How Do I Report It?
Anyone who reports corruption has the right to have their identity kept confidential. Here is where to file, what to include, and how you are prote...
-
Administrative
I Applied for a Permit and the Agency Won't Answer: What Is Positive Silence?
If you applied for a permit or license and the agency did not decide in time, the law may treat it as approved. Here is when that applies and how t...
Comments
Loading comments…
Thank you. Your comment is awaiting review and will be published if it complies with the comment policy.