Ciudad Quesada, San Carlos, Costa Rica · Barrio San Martín (Gamonales), across from the EBAIS (public health clinic) Phone +506 2460-7226 [email protected]

Administrative

I Applied for a Permit and the Agency Won't Answer: What Is Positive Silence?

If you applied for a permit or license and the agency did not decide in time, the law may treat it as approved. Here is when that applies and how to enforce it.

Translated from the Spanish original. If there is any discrepancy between the two versions, the Spanish text prevails. Read the original in Spanish.

Imagine you want to open a small food stand in your garage. You filed your license application with the municipality, with all the documents, you were given a file number, and you were told to wait. Months go by and no one decides, while you keep paying for the equipment without being able to open. For these cases, Costa Rican law has a specific answer: positive silence (silencio positivo).

What is positive silence?

As a general rule, if the Public Administration does not answer, it is understood to have said no. The General Public Administration Act provides that once the deadline passes without an answer, the claim or petition is deemed denied, so that the person can file the appropriate appeals or go to court.

With permits, licenses, and authorizations, the rule is the opposite: the agency’s silence is understood as positive, that is, as an approval. The Act to Protect Citizens from Excessive Requirements and Administrative Procedures confirms this: if the deadline to decide expires and the agency has not ruled, the application is deemed approved by operation of law, provided the person has met the legal requirements.

How long do you have to wait?

The deadline is the one set by the rules governing that specific procedure. If there is no special deadline, the General Public Administration Act applies: one month from the date the agency receives the application with all the requirements complete. For a municipal business license (licencia municipal), the Municipal Code sets thirty calendar days: once they pass with no response and the requirements are met, the applicant may start the business.

That word “complete” matters. The agency must review the documents and, if something is missing, notify you in writing, and only once, of what you must correct (prevención); afterward, it cannot ask for new requirements that it did not point out in that notice. The notice suspends the deadline, and you have up to ten business days to comply; after that, the deadline resumes. The regulations under that law add that the agency has three business days to issue that notice, unless another rule sets a different period.

In addition, the only requirements that count are those found in laws, decrees, regulations, or general resolutions that are published in the National Catalog of Procedures (Catálogo Nacional de Trámites).

How do you enforce it?

Positive silence takes effect on its own, but in practice you have to give notice of it. All you need is to file a sworn statement (declaración jurada) stating that the agency did not decide within the deadline and that you met the requirements. It can be made before a notary public (civil-law notary), signed in the presence of the official, or filed as an electronic document with a digital signature. Once it receives the statement, the agency has two business days to issue the resolution confirming the permit, license, or authorization.

Once positive silence has taken effect, the agency cannot later issue a denial or refuse to recognize it. If it believes you did not meet the requirements, it must follow a formal annulment procedure or go to court to prove it.

When does it not apply?

The law excludes permits, licenses, and authorizations in matters of public health and the environment, and those matters for which the Constitution, a statute, or court precedent expressly so provides. Each agency must indicate in the National Catalog of Procedures the cases in which it does not apply.

A single business may need several permits: perhaps the municipal license is deemed approved, but a health permit, being a public health matter, is not.

Nor does it work if the application was incomplete: if the agency notified you of a defect and you did not correct it, the application cannot be declared approved by silence.

What if the official refuses?

The law classifies it as a very serious offense for an official or agency head to fail to follow the positive silence procedure or to fail to issue the confirming resolution on time, punishable by suspension without pay for eight to thirty days. You can also hold the agency, the official, and their superior accountable. The regulations allow you to file a complaint, in writing or verbally, with the agency’s citizen information office or with the hierarchical superior.

Practical recommendations

  1. Keep proof of the filing date. Ask for the received stamp or the electronic receipt: the deadline is calculated from that date.
  2. Check the National Catalog of Procedures. It should show what requirements your procedure involves and whether the agency excluded it from positive silence.
  3. Respond to any notice to correct within ten business days. If you do not, you lose the ability to claim positive silence.
  4. Before signing the sworn statement, confirm that you met every requirement. An inaccurate statement can cost you the permit. And if you have several permits pending, review each one separately.

Need help?

A mistake in calculating the deadline or preparing the sworn statement can cost you months. At Murillo y Guzmán we can review your file and assist you before the agency. Book a consultation.

This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice for any specific case. To discuss your situation, book a consultation.

All insights Share

Related insights

Comments

Loading comments…