ConstitutionalAccess to Public Information
I Wrote to a Public Agency and Got No Answer: What Is the Right to Petition?
A public agency must answer your petition within ten business days. Who may petition, the requirements, what the answer must say and what to do if none comes.
Translated from the Spanish original. If there is any discrepancy between the two versions, the Spanish text prevails. Read the original in Spanish.
In this article9 sections
The neighbors on a street with no sidewalks sign a letter asking the municipality to build them before the school year starts. A farmer writes to a ministry to ask why a support program was suspended. Weeks go by and no one answers, not even to say no. The Constitution (Constitución Política) guarantees the right to address any public official or entity and to obtain a prompt resolution, and the Law Regulating the Right to Petition (Ley de Regulación del Derecho de Petición) sets out how it is exercised and how soon the answer must come. This right resembles the right to request public information, but is not the same; we explain the difference below.
Who may petition, and whom?
Anyone, of any nationality, alone or with others, without suffering any harm or penalty for it. It may be addressed to any public institution or authority on matters within its competence, and to private individuals or companies that carry out an activity of public interest, handle public funds, or exercise some public authority.
The subject may be any matter, issue, or information of a public nature.
What are the requirements?
Very few. The petition is made in writing, signed, and includes your name, your national ID card (cédula) or identity document number, what you request, and to whom. If written in a foreign language, attach a translation or summary in Spanish. In group petitions, each person signs next to their full name; anyone who does not sign is not a petitioner, though the petition can be completed later. If an agency regulation or circular demands other requirements, the law says informality prevails, so they do not become an obstacle.
In writing does not mean on paper. The Constitutional Chamber (Sala Constitucional) has said a petition may be emailed to the address the agency designates for requests. In 2025 it granted an amparo action (recurso de amparo) against a municipality that could not show it had an official email address for filings: it ordered it to set one up within a month and deliver what was requested within five days, and to pay costs, damages, and lost profits, to be quantified later in the contentious-administrative courts.
How soon must they respond?
The agency must acknowledge receipt and respond within ten business days (días hábiles), excluding weekends and holidays, counted from the day after receipt. If you deliver your letter on a Monday with no holidays in between, the period starts Tuesday and ends on the Monday two weeks later.
The law calls that period non-extendable but allows one extension: if the matter is complex, the agency may send a partial response explaining so and take up to five more business days for the final one.
If the petition is incomplete or unclear, the agency must ask you to correct it within five business days; if you do not, it is closed. If they only ask for supplementary information or documents and you do not provide them, they must still respond.
If you addressed the wrong agency, it must forward the petition to the competent one within five business days and inform you. If you picked the wrong office within the same agency, it is transferred internally, you are informed, and the ten-day period keeps running.
What must the response say?
An acknowledgment of receipt is not enough. The response must explain how the petition was considered and the reasons it is granted or not; any measure adopted must be attached. If the agency finds the petition has merit, it must act on it and adopt the measures it deems appropriate to give it effect.
The law does not require the agency to agree with you, but it does require a reasoned answer. The Constitutional Chamber sums it up this way: it is “the right to ask and not the right to obtain what is asked for.”
Apart from the wrong-agency case, the law bars admitting a petition that affects the fundamental rights of others, is unreasonable or disproportionate, seeks to delay another proceeding, or is frivolous (plainly groundless). That rejection must be reasoned and served on you.
Asking for an answer or asking for information?
The Constitution deals separately with two rights that look alike: the right to petition, to address the authorities and receive an answer, and the right of access to information, to learn what is on record in public offices on matters of public interest. The regulation of the Framework Law on Access to Public Information (Ley Marco de Acceso a la Información Pública) defines them along the same lines.
The practical difference lies in what you ask for:
- If you ask for an explanation or propose that the agency take action, like the farmer or the neighbors in the opening example, you are exercising the right to petition: you are entitled to a reasoned answer, not to obtain what you ask for.
- If you ask for documents or data that already exist, such as a public works contract, meeting minutes, or a payroll, you are mainly exercising the right of access to information: there you are entitled to obtain them unless the law protects them.
The two rights overlap. The regulation considers that anyone requesting public information exercises both the right to petition and the right of access at once. The Constitutional Chamber also protects them together: in 2025 it ordered a municipal district council (concejo municipal de distrito) to deliver within three days its staff attendance report, which it had refused, finding that the refusal violated the right to petition because the report was of public interest and not protected by personal data rules.
That does not mean every rule of the right-to-petition law applies to a request for information. If you want a document or data, it is best to file a request for information, because the Framework Law on Access to Public Information has rules designed for that: the request can be oral, written, or electronic, without explaining why; what is already in the agency’s records and easily accessible is delivered immediately; and a refusal must state the legal limit it relies on. In exchange, in complex matters the agency may extend the deadline up to one month if it notifies you and justifies it within the ten business days. If they do not answer, you can also go to the Constitutional Chamber. We explain how to file that request in this publication on how to request public information, and what the regulation added in the article on the regulation of that law.
When is it not a simple petition?
The Law Regulating the Right to Petition does not apply to requests that already have their own procedure and deadlines, such as applying for a permit or appealing a decision. According to the Constitutional Chamber, a simple petition seeks an answer, while a formal application opens a procedure that ends in a formal agency decision. If the agency rejects your letter for that reason, it must tell you which rules govern your request and which body is competent. The line has not always been clear for requests for public works. In 2008, neighbors asked for a road to be paved; the Chamber treated it as a formal application and dismissed the amparo action. Months later, in a similar case, it did order a written answer because the wait had been disproportionate.
The difference also changes where to complain. If a formal application is delayed, the Constitutional Chamber dismisses the amparo action, except in some cases, such as environmental or corruption complaints, salary payments, drinking water or electricity, or certain matters involving minors, older adults, or persons with disabilities. Otherwise, you must complain to the Contentious-Administrative Court (Tribunal Contencioso Administrativo) through a so-called legality amparo (amparo de legalidad); the Chamber does not transfer it for you. We explain this in this publication on amparo and habeas corpus.
What if they do not answer?
No response within the deadline, a response lacking the minimum content the law requires, or an ambiguous or partial response without justification can be taken to the Constitutional Chamber through an amparo action. Against a private individual or company, amparo is available only exceptionally, for example if it performs public functions. The Chamber may accept that a complex matter needed more time than the law’s five additional days, if reasonable, but it has required the agency to explain this to you within the ten business days.
The law also provides that an official who fails to answer a simple petition on time (one not part of a formal application with its own procedure) be fined five percent of one monthly base salary (salario base), a figure the Supreme Court of Justice announces yearly in La Gaceta, the official gazette. The law does not say who imposes the penalty or how, and it punishes the official; it is not a payment to you.
Practical recommendations
- Get a date-stamped receipt, or keep the acknowledgment of receipt if you write online: the response deadline depends on that date.
- Be specific. State what you request and from whom, and include your name, ID number, and signature. Also give a way to receive the response; in a request for information, this is mandatory.
- In group petitions, check that each person signs next to their full name.
- If you write online, use the official email address or the form on the agency’s website, and sign the document, with a digital signature or by attaching the signed letter. An email to another address has been accepted when the agency processed it, but it is better not to risk it.
- If what you want is a document or a piece of data, file it as a request for information. If you are also asking for an explanation or proposing that the agency take action, do so in a separate filing.
- Check whether your matter has its own procedure. If it is a permit, a payment, or an appeal, use that procedure and its deadlines. If you were already served with a decision affecting you, asking for explanations does not stop the deadline to appeal it, which may be as short as three business days.
Need help?
A well-drafted petition makes a useful answer more likely and, if none arrives, lays the groundwork for a complaint. At Murillo y Guzmán we can help you prepare your letter and decide what to do if the agency does not respond. Book a consultation.
This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice for any specific case. To discuss your situation, book a consultation.
Related insights
-
Constitutional
When Can I File an Amparo Action or a Habeas Corpus Petition?
What amparo and habeas corpus protect, when they do not apply, when the legality amparo is the right path, how to file them, and the deadlines to k...
-
Access to Public Information
When Can Public Information Be Denied to Me? The Limits the Law Allows and the Abuses It Forbids
Only the Constitution, a treaty or a statute can limit access to public information. What a denial must say and which abuses are forbidden.
-
Administrative
I'm a Party to an Administrative Proceeding: What Can I See in the File?
If you are a party to a proceeding, you can review and copy your file. Which documents can be withheld, whether your attorney needs a power, and ho...
Comments
Loading comments…
Thank you. Your comment is awaiting review and will be published if it complies with the comment policy.