Can a Criminal Case Be Resolved by Repairing the Harm, Without Going to Trial?
The Restorative Justice Law lets the victim and the accused agree on how to repair the harm. When it applies, how it works, and what happens if it is breached.
Translated from the Spanish original. If there is any discrepancy between the two versions, the Spanish text prevails. Read the original in Spanish.
During a traffic argument, a young man breaks another driver’s side mirror and leaves a dent in the door. Days later he learns that there is a criminal case against him. He regrets it and wants to pay for the damage, but he does not know whether that makes any difference once the case is already with the prosecutor’s office. The victim, for his part, is not looking to have him jailed: he wants his car repaired and an apology. Restorative justice exists for situations like this one, under the Restorative Justice Law (Ley de Justicia Restaurativa).
What is restorative justice?
It is a way of resolving the conflict arising from a crime with the active participation of the victim and the offender. Its purpose is to repair the harm to the victim, help the person who caused it reintegrate into society, and promote social peace.
At the core of the procedure is the restorative meeting: a structured dialogue, arranged in a circle and guided by a judge, in which the victim, the offender, their support persons, and the community talk about the harm caused and build a solution together. The result is a reparation plan, which may consist of a payment, the delivery of property, doing or refraining from doing something, community service, rehabilitation, educational programs, or any other form of reparation the victim requests.
When does it apply?
It may be requested by the Public Prosecutor’s Office (Ministerio Público), the defense, the judge, the police, the victim, or the offender, and it can be used only once. It is available at different stages of the proceedings, for example:
- Before trial, when the case allows for a settlement (conciliación), full reparation of the harm, or suspension of the proceedings on probation (suspensión del proceso a prueba), which are alternatives that end the case without a judgment.
- In the abbreviated procedure or at trial, to set the sentence when a suspended sentence (ejecución condicional) is possible, that is, when the sentence does not exceed three years in prison and may be suspended, or when the penalty is not imprisonment.
- In misdemeanors (contravenciones), which are minor criminal offenses.
The law expressly excludes sexual crimes, crimes of violence against women (except certain economic crimes without violence against persons), crimes arising from domestic violence, violations of the drug law (with one specific exception), organized crime, and human trafficking.
What is required to take part?
First, the accused must already have given their statement to the Public Prosecutor’s Office, and there must be sufficient evidence linking them to the facts. Next, the offender must acknowledge the harm and be willing to repair it, both the offender and the victim must sign an informed consent, and the Judiciary’s psychosocial team must issue a favorable opinion.
That team may recommend not going forward if it detects a power imbalance between the parties or a risk to the victim, or if the offender does not acknowledge the harm or the victim does not want to take part. If there are several victims and not all of them agree, the case returns to the ordinary track.
How does it work, and what happens next?
The law sets short deadlines: no more than one month may pass between the case’s arrival at the restorative justice office and the meeting, or ten days if the case is handled under the expedited procedure for offenses caught in the act (flagrancia). If there is an agreement, the judge reviews it immediately at a hearing and, if it complies with the law, approves it with binding effect. If the agreement is not subject to a deadline, a final dismissal (sobreseimiento definitivo) that closes the case is issued on the spot; if it has a deadline, follow-up hearings are scheduled.
Two safeguards are important. Participation is voluntary, and anyone may withdraw before the judge approves the agreements. And what is said at the meeting is confidential: it cannot be used in the ordinary proceedings or treated as a confession. If the offender fails to comply without justification, the measure is revoked and the case returns to the ordinary track.
Practical recommendations
- Ask about this option from the start. The victim has the right to be informed about it, and the accused can request it through their defense attorney.
- Offer only what you can deliver. The reparation plan must take into account the offender’s financial and personal circumstances, and a failure to comply sends the case back to the ordinary proceedings.
- Keep the record in mind. Alternative resolutions are recorded in the Judicial Registry (Registro Judicial) for five years.
- Do not go alone. Both parties may bring a support person and have legal advice.
Need help?
Whether a case qualifies for restorative justice depends on the offense, the stage of the proceedings, and each party’s situation. At Murillo y Guzmán we can assess whether this route suits your case, whether you are the victim or the accused, and guide you at every step. Book a consultation.
This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice for any specific case. To discuss your situation, book a consultation.
Related insights
-
Criminal
I Was Asked to Lend My Bank Account to Receive Money: What Risk Am I Taking?
Lending your account to receive someone else's money can end in criminal proceedings. Which laws may apply, what self-fraud is, and what banks report.
-
Criminal
Money Was Taken from My Account Online or Through a Fake Call: What Do I Do?
If money was taken from your account by a fake call or online, a 2026 law gives you deadlines and rights against your financial institution. What t...
-
Administrative
I Know of Corruption in a Public Institution: How Do I Report It?
Anyone who reports corruption has the right to have their identity kept confidential. Here is where to file, what to include, and how you are prote...
Comments
Loading comments…
Thank you. Your comment is awaiting review and will be published if it complies with the comment policy.