Ciudad Quesada, San Carlos, Costa Rica · Barrio San Martín (Gamonales), across from the EBAIS (public health clinic) Phone +506 2460-7226 [email protected]

AgrarianLeases and Rentals

Leasing Land for Crops or Cattle: What Should the Contract Say?

A farmland lease is not governed by the residential rental law. What to agree on regarding term, rent, crops, livestock, and a sale of the property.

Translated from the Spanish original. If there is any discrepancy between the two versions, the Spanish text prevails. Read the original in Spanish.

A farmer leases ten hectares of his neighbor’s pasture, and everything is settled with a handshake. Two years later, the owner sells the property and the buyer asks him to leave, just when the herd is complete. Or think of the woman who leases a plot to grow beans and, halfway through the season, the owner tells her he needs the land back. Almost all of these disputes have the same origin: a contract that was never put in writing or that leaves out what matters.

Which law applies to leasing land for production?

It is not the law that governs renting a house. The Urban and Suburban Leases Act (Ley General de Arrendamientos Urbanos y Suburbanos) excludes contracts whose main purpose is the agricultural, livestock, or forestry use of the land, even if the property includes a house. Those contracts are governed by the Civil Code (Código Civil): by its general lease rules and by a chapter of its own for “rural properties” (predios rústicos), that is, land used for farming or ranching.

Disputes arising from these contracts are heard by the agrarian courts.

What should be put in writing?

If the contract is silent, rules apply that can surprise either party:

  • The land and its size. The owner must deliver the area stated in the contract. It is advisable to identify the property by its National Registry number and its registered survey map (plano catastrado), and to list what is included: corrals, sheds, water.
  • The rent. It can be a sum of money or a fixed quantity of the harvest. If what was agreed cannot later be proven, the owner’s word is taken, unless the tenant asks for the rent to be set by experts.
  • Permitted use. The land must be used for the agreed purpose. If the use is changed or the land is abused, the owner may ask that things be restored and, if the breach is serious, that the contract be terminated with damages.
  • The term. If no term was set, either party may end the contract with prior notice; if rent is paid yearly, the lease ends six months after the notice.
  • Subleasing. Unless the contract expressly prohibits it, the tenant may sublease or assign the contract.

Bad harvests, livestock, and standing crops

The Civil Code has rules of its own for rural land:

  • A bad harvest does not reduce the rent. The tenant cannot ask for a reduction on the grounds of unforeseeable events that damaged or destroyed the harvest. If the parties want to share that risk, for example in case of drought, they must agree on it.
  • If the property is leased with livestock, the animals are at the tenant’s risk, and at the end the tenant must return the same number of head, of the same ages and qualities, or their value in money.
  • Standing crops. Once the contract ends, the tenant may use the land for the time strictly necessary to gather the crops that are ready to be harvested.
  • The land is returned as it was received. If no written record of its condition was made, the tenant is presumed to have received it in good condition.

What happens if the owner sells the property?

If the lease is not recorded, the buyer only has to honor it for one year from the time the tenant is given notice, and does not have to honor one that is not set out in a public or private document with a certain date. A lease can be recorded in the National Registry (Registro Nacional), and it only affects third parties if it was recorded. For a long lease, or one involving significant investments, it is advisable to execute it as a public deed (escritura pública) and record it.

The death of the owner or the tenant, on the other hand, does not end the contract.

What if the tenant has to be removed?

The owner may request eviction before the agrarian court through eviction proceedings (desahucio). The grounds include expiration of the term, nonpayment, abusive use, an unauthorized change of use or sublease, and abandonment of the property. If there are standing crops when the judgment becomes final, the tenant may ask, within the following eight days, that delivery be postponed for the time strictly necessary to harvest, by posting security for or depositing the rent for that period.

Practical recommendations

  1. Always sign a written contract, with a certain date, or as a public deed if the term is long.
  2. Make an inventory of the condition of the property and the livestock at the start, signed by both parties.
  3. Agree on how the risk of a bad harvest will be shared, because the law places it on the tenant.
  4. Set the term according to the production cycle and state what happens to the crops when it ends.
  5. Review the title search (estudio registral) before signing. If the land is a parcel granted by the Rural Development Institute (Instituto de Desarrollo Rural, INDER), the owner may need the institute’s authorization to lease it.

Need help?

Every type of farming operation carries different risks. At Murillo y Guzmán we can draft or review your land lease and, if a dispute has already arisen, represent you. Book a consultation.

This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice for any specific case. To discuss your situation, book a consultation.

All insights Share

Related insights

Comments

Loading comments…