BankingConsumer ProtectionCriminal
I Was Scammed and My Financial Institution Won't Return the Money: Where Can I File a Claim?
A claim with the institution, review by Sugef, the National Consumer Commission, civil or administrative courts, and the criminal case: what each path offers.
Translated from the Spanish original. If there is any discrepancy between the two versions, the Spanish text prevails. Read the original in Spanish.
Money was taken from your account through a fake phone call, and your financial institution rejected your claim, or does not answer. Some people tell you to go to the MEIC; others, to Sugef or to a judge. Not all of these serve the same purpose. The law that governs electronic fraud claims allows you to turn to the appropriate administrative or judicial path at any time.
Where should you start?
With a claim before the institution itself, on its form, with a copy of the criminal complaint filed with the Judicial Investigation Agency (Organismo de Investigación Judicial, OIJ), and within thirty calendar days after the events. It is the fastest path, with short deadlines and consequences if the institution is late. We explain how to file it step by step.
What role does Sugef play?
If the institution rejects the claim, it must send the decision, with its forensic analysis or log, to the OIJ and to the General Superintendency of Financial Entities (Superintendencia General de Entidades Financieras, Sugef), which has ten business days to validate whether the rejection is supported by the evidence. If Sugef does not ratify it, the institution must return the funds within ten business days; if it confirms it, you may go to court. You do not have to request that review yourself.
Beyond that, the law does not task Sugef with resolving individual claims; it does task it with sanctioning an institution that fails to meet its obligations, which does not get your money back.
What about the MEIC’s National Consumer Commission?
It is a body attached to the Ministry of Economy, Industry and Commerce (Ministerio de Economía, Industria y Comercio, MEIC) that oversees the consumer protection law, the same law that makes financial institutions liable even without fault. The law does not exclude them from the Commission’s jurisdiction; the only express exception is that the Commission cannot annul unfair terms in financial adhesion contracts.
It may sanction violations and order, when appropriate, the return of money, an order that is collected through payment-order proceedings (proceso monitorio). It may not hear claims for compensation for damages, which are left to the courts. Whether it may order the institution to reimburse what a third party took, as a return of money rather than as compensation, is something the law does not expressly say.
The complaint requires no formalities and expires six months after the violation or after it became known, extendable for six more months if you show that within that period the institution did not resolve the matter to your satisfaction.
Which court hears the lawsuit?
- Private institution. The case goes to the civil courts, which handle civil and commercial proceedings. The consumer protection law refers to summary proceedings (proceso sumario), and the case may be filed in the court of your domicile or of the place where the events occurred.
- State-owned bank. State-owned banks are autonomous public-law institutions, so the lawsuit goes to the contentious-administrative courts, which hear matters involving the conduct of the decentralized public administration and its financial liability. For example, in a 2012 case, before the electronic fraud law, the Administrative Litigation Court (Tribunal Contencioso Administrativo) ordered a state-owned bank to reimburse what had been taken through online banking fraud.
In both paths the burden of proof is reversed in favor of the consumer, and damages may be claimed.
Can I file a claim within the criminal case?
Yes. Through the civil compensation action (acción civil resarcitoria), which is the claim for money within the criminal case, the victim seeks restitution and damages from the perpetrators and from whoever, under the law, is liable for the harm, even if the perpetrator has not been identified. The victim must become a civil plaintiff (actor civil), with an attorney, before the Public Prosecutor’s Office (Ministerio Público) and before it files its formal charging request.
The civil action depends on the criminal prosecution continuing; if the prosecution is suspended, the right to sue through another path is preserved. It cannot be pursued in the criminal case and in the civil courts at the same time. The consumer protection law adds that the administrative and judicial paths do not exclude each other, unless you choose the judicial path.
Practical recommendations
- Always file the claim with the institution and the criminal complaint with the OIJ.
- Ask for a copy of the decision and its analysis, and ask whether Sugef ratified it.
- Write down the deadlines: thirty calendar days to file a claim with the institution and six months to file a complaint with the Commission.
- Do not duplicate your claim in paths that exclude each other, and decide whether you are seeking only the return of the money or damages as well.
Need help?
Each case requires its own analysis. At Murillo y Guzmán we can review your case and assist you before the institution, the Commission, or the courts. Book a consultation.
This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice for any specific case. To discuss your situation, book a consultation.
Related insights
-
Banking
Am I Being Charged Usurious Interest? The Maximum Rate the Law Allows
The law caps the interest rate on loans and credit cards. Here is how the cap is calculated, where to look it up, and what to do if you are overcha...
-
Banking
I Was Scammed Online: Is My Bank Liable Even if It Was Not at Fault?
Since 2026, your financial institution is liable for money a third party takes from your account, even without fault. Exceptions and burden of proof.
-
Banking
Fake Links and Stolen Phone Numbers: How Do I Avoid a Banking Scam?
What SIM swapping is, how to spot fake links and apps, what your financial institution must teach you, and what to do if you are being scammed.
Comments
Loading comments…
Thank you. Your comment is awaiting review and will be published if it complies with the comment policy.